BPSC PT 71

Q. The constitution of India provides for reasonable restrictions on Fundamental Rights but reasonableness must keep in mind that :

1) The interest of the general public is safeguarded
2) Prevailing social value and also social needs are not bar
3) Directive principles can be bypassed
4) Collective good is not greater
Out of these:
a) Only 4 is correct
b) 2 and 3 are correct
c) 1 and 2 are correct
d) Only 1 is correct
Correct Answer : c) 1 and 2 are correct

Question from BPSC PT 71, 2025

Correct Answer: c) 1 and 2 are correct

Explanation:
– The Constitution allows “reasonable restrictions” on certain Fundamental Rights (especially under Article 19) to balance individual liberty with public interest.
– While judging reasonableness, courts look at factors like the purpose of the law, the nature of the right, the extent of the restriction, and the social context.

Check each statement:
1) The interest of the general public is safeguarded — Correct.
– Articles 19(2)–(6) explicitly allow restrictions in the interests of the general/public interest. The test of reasonableness balances individual rights with public welfare (V.G. Row, Chintaman Rao).

2) Prevailing social value and also social needs are not bar — Correct (read as: they are relevant and must be considered).
– Courts assess reasonableness in light of prevailing social values and social needs of the time (Pathumma v. State of Kerala).

3) Directive principles can be bypassed — Incorrect.
– Part III (Fundamental Rights) and Part IV (Directive Principles) must be harmonized; DPSPs cannot be ignored or “bypassed.” Restrictions are often upheld to implement DPSPs (Minerva Mills).

4) Collective good is not greater — Incorrect.
– The very idea of reasonable restrictions recognizes that collective/public interest can outweigh individual liberty in appropriate cases.

Therefore, statements 1 and 2 are correct; 3 and 4 are incorrect.

Check Demo Video

UPSC Factory

Master UPSC offline! 📚🎯 4000+ Prelims PYQs, Mains model answers, NCERT books, Syllabus tracker, topper notes, past papers.
Give it a try, you will love it !!💯

UPSC Factory for Android
Conquer UPSC offline! 🚀 PYQs (Prelims & Mains), Test Series, Syllabus Tracker.
Give it a try, you will love it 💯