Explanation :
To determine the unique values of x and y (distinct natural numbers) that satisfy the given conditions, let’s analyze each statement individually and then consider them together.
Statement I: x/y is odd.
Interpretation: For x/y to be an odd integer, x must be an odd multiple of y. This implies that y must be a divisor of x, and the quotient x/y must be an odd number.
Limitations: Without additional information, there are multiple pairs (x, y) that can satisfy this condition. For example:
– x = 3, y = 1 (since 3/1 = 3 is odd)
– x = 9, y = 3 (since 9/3 = 3 is odd)
Conclusion: Statement I alone is insufficient to determine unique values of x and y.
Statement II: xy = 12.
Interpretation: The product of x and y is 12. Considering that x and y are distinct natural numbers, the possible pairs are:
– (1, 12)
– (2, 6)
– (3, 4)
Limitations: Multiple valid pairs satisfy this condition.
Conclusion: Statement II alone is insufficient to determine unique values of x and y.
Combining Statements I and II:
Now, let’s use both statements together.
1. From Statement II, the possible pairs are (1, 12), (2, 6), and (3, 4).
2. Applying Statement I (x/y is odd) to each pair:
– (1, 12): 1/12 is not an integer, so this pair is invalid.
– (2, 6): 2/6 = 1/3 is not an integer, so this pair is invalid.
– (3, 4): 3/4 is not an integer, so this pair appears invalid at first glance.
However, there’s a misunderstanding here. For x/y to be an odd integer, x must be a multiple of y, and the quotient must itself be odd.
Re-examining the possible pairs:
– (12, 1): 12/1 = 12 (Even)
– (6, 2): 6/2 = 3 (Odd)
– (4, 3): 4/3 is not an integer.
Valid Pair: (6, 2) since 6/2 = 3 is an odd integer.
Conclusion: Using both statements together, the unique values are x = 6 and y = 2.
Therefore, option c is the correct choice.