2025 Paper 2

Q. What are the Private and Public network and support systems operative in Indian society for the aged? Suggest measures to curb down the challenges before care givers of the aged.

UPSC Sociology 2025 Paper 2

Model Answer:

The UNFPA India Ageing Report 2023 projects that the elderly will constitute 20% of India’s population by 2050. This rapid “demographic shift” is fundamentally altering traditional kinship and family structures, necessitating a robust evolution in both private and public care mechanisms.

Support Networks and Systems

Private Support Networks:

  • Family and Kinship: Despite residential nuclearization, A.M. Shah argues that “functional jointness” (financial and emotional ties) persists. However, Sarah Lamb observes a shift from traditional Seva (unquestioned duty) to “negotiated care,” especially alongside diaspora migration.
  • Market and Civil Society: There is a growing “commodification of care” (paid care workers, premium retirement communities) serving the urban upper-middle class, contrasting starkly with the severe destitution faced by the rural poor, where NGOs attempt to bridge the gap.

Public Support Systems:

  • State Interventions: The Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act (2007) and schemes like IGNOAPS provide the formal framework.
  • Sociological Critique: Demographer S. Irudaya Rajan critiques these systems, noting that state pensions are meager and systematically exclude the vast informal sector workforce. Additionally, the state often frames the elderly as “dependents” requiring charity rather than citizens with rights.

Challenges for Caregivers

  • Feminization of Caregiving: In India’s patriarchal setup, elder care falls disproportionately on women, specifically the daughter-in-law.
  • Intersectionality and Stress: The “sandwich generation” faces immense “emotional labour” (Arlie Hochschild). These challenges vary across class and caste: urban middle-class caregivers face psychological stress (time poverty), while landless Dalit households face extreme material deprivation.
  • Structural Lag: Increased longevity has resulted in what Matilda White Riley terms “structural lag”—where demographic changes have outpaced the evolution of supportive social institutions.

Addressing caregiver challenges requires multifaceted measures:

  • Formalizing the Care Economy: Recognizing unpaid female labor through state caregiver allowances and subsidized geriatric healthcare.
  • Rebuilding Social Capital: Establishing state-supported respite care, day-care centers, and neighborhood support groups to relieve isolated caregivers.
  • Workplace Flexibility: Introducing paid elder-care leave and flexible hours to prevent caregiver drop-out from the labor force.

Conclusion

Addressing India’s aging population requires shifting the narrative from viewing the elderly as a “demographic burden” to recognizing them as a vital social resource. Bridging traditional Dharma with modern, rights-based state welfare is essential for fostering “intergenerational solidarity” and ensuring dignified aging in a transitioning society.

UPSC Factory for Android
Mains PYQ's with Diagram, Prelims PYQs, Test Series.
Give it a try, you will love it 💯
Sociology App for Android
🎯 Ace UPSC Optional: Mains PYQs with Diagrams + Current Affairs. Download App!
Sociology App for Android
📚 2013-25 PYQ answers with diagrams, current affairs, syllabus tracker, & IGNOU books! You'll be amazed this exists. 💪 हिंदी में भी!
Sociology Optional App for Android
Get Model Answers of PYQ's with Diagrams, Current Affairs, Syllabus Tracker, IGNOU Books, Topper Note. Click to Download !!